Danish writer-director Scherfig and London-based actress-turned-director Andrea Arnold have fashioned two very different movies on similar themes. An Education is about a bright young teen (Carey Mulligan) who breaks out of her stifling middle class life via a suave rake (Peter Sarsgaard) who sweeps her off her feet. She emerges sadder and wiser. So does the lower class teen in Arnold's Fish Tank , which is an intense mother-daughter tale about what happens when a sexy man (Michael Fassbender) moves into the house and actually treats both his girlfriend and her neglected daughters better than anyone else ever has.
Arnold prefers to work with non-pros, but decided to cast Fassbender rather than go with her local garbage man in the role of the charming seducer of a rebellious young teen. "I thought maybe it would be too tough on everybody having inexperienced actors," she says. "Katie Jarvis had such a huge job, she's in every scene. So I decided to cast an actor who has seen more life than they have." She withheld the script, doling pages out in sections to keep the actors focused on the here and now. The actors used her scripts, but added some local color to the dialogue. For the film's tour-de-force climactic chase through the park, Arnold was only able to shoot two takes. "You have to think on your feet," she says. "Everything becomes live and real."
My Telluride flip cam conversation with Scherfig and Mulligan, in two parts, is on the jump: