Click to Skip Ad
Closing in...

'Treme' Season 3, Ep. 2: A Deep Specificity of Culture

Television
by Terry Curtis Fox
October 1, 2012 2:00 AM
2 Comments
  • |

Decades ago, I'd heard that Eric Overmeyer and the wonderful actress Ellen McElduff had begun living part-time in her native Louisiana. This is obviously well before Katrina, but even then, New Orleans was in need of support. Cajun culture was having its brief moment in the sun, but the city and state were already in severe economic distress. The kind of contemporary work Eric and Ellen were doing in the theatre was, to put it mildly, absent. (I haven't seen either in years, but I've long been an admirer of both of their work and have had passing acquaintance with them.)

Overmeyer -- who gets this season's only sole credit on this week's episode of "Treme" -- is the co-creator of the series but has understandably been treated as the secondary figure in the partnership with David Simon.

His contribution, however, should not be underestimated. Overmeyer writes about New Orleans with the authenticity that Simon brought to Baltimore. Specificity of place has long been a hallmark of HBO series. But what "Treme" has is a deep specificity of culture.

This is why music is not an add-on. In a city with no governance, culture is what sustains. It's a music deeply rooted in tradition (another thematic issue which I'll discuss as the season progresses) and cuts across racial and class lines.

[Spoiler alert]

There are two characters who return to the city in this season. One is the modern jazz musician, Delmond Lambreaux, whose story is about forging an alliance between his internationalist jazz present and his parochial roots. The other is chef Janette Desautel, who begins this season working for David Chang in New York. (With Chang, Anthony Bourdain, and Emeril Lagasse involved in the series, the kitchen scenes have a remarkable ring of truth. Making drama about food is not easy: for one thing, smell can only be portrayed indirectly. And while talent can be demonstrated, it cannot be acted. There's a reason that Antoine Batiste commits to teaching this season; Wendell Pierce can act up a storm, but he cannot play at the level of the show's musicians. We can hear the quality of the music on screen. It's only the absolute authenticity of the restaurant scenes that allows us to believe that Desautel is truly a great cook.)

Culture draws Desautel back to New Orleans as surely as it does Delmond. She's wooed twice in the first two episodes -- and chooses the wrong partner. (She's great at judging dishes and kitchen workers; not so great at judging men when partnership – business or culinary – is concerned.)

Most of the musicians in show are looking backwards. (There's an extended sequence in this episode and others in which Batiste introduces his students to the ultra-traditional Preservation Hall; as a result of his fusion record with his father, Delmond and Albert are wooed by financiers for a tourist-oriented museum of jazz.)

The cooking portrayed on screen is modernist, far more cosmopolitan than anything else in the series. Like the three real chefs, Desautel is high-end. Her kitchen may be racially mixed but her product is very much for the upper-class (unlike the music, which is for everyone). But while it is forward-thinking, it's also something that draws from the city's particular culture and resources. (Later in the season, she gives a wonderful rant against frozen crayfish; seasons are seasons in her world. In yet another story line, we see those crayfish being harvested by Vietnamese fishermen, a story about how cultures are absorbed and occupations replenished.)

That forward-looking food is essential. It's an essential part of the culture, and it's aimed at the future. Desautel's battle is to keep the city from becoming a museum. Among the devastation, her story is about culture as a living, changing, force.

It's a tough, ambiguous, but, in the end, hopeful story, one that is as central to the series as the stories of despair.   
 

Television
  • |

More: TV Reviews, Treme, HBO, Television, Reviews

2 Comments

  • AccidentalVisitor | October 2, 2012 3:17 PMReply

    >> Wait. I don't think Pierce has ever been "performing". He is just pretending from what I have read and the music is later added on. Maybe you meant to write that Antoine, the character he plays, cannot play at the level of the show's musicians (characters). And that would make sense because there is a bit of a running joke that despite Antoine being an above average musician he is not on the level of many of the other folks he comes across. Anyway the point is that Pierce is no more playing the music than Rob Brown is as the ultra-talented Delmond. They are both actors pretending to be music artists. The only truly great musician amongst the main cast is the woman who plays Annie.

  • Geoffrey Altrocchi | October 1, 2012 2:56 AMReply

    Anything from the guy who did "The Wire" will do just fine!

Free Indie Movies and Documentaries    

Email Updates

Most "Liked"

  • First Reviews of Woody Allen's 'Magic ...
  • Best of the Week: Peter Biskind's New ...
  • Summer Box Office Freefall Continues ...
  • Academy Elects New Board of Governors: ...
  • Will Mark Romanek Follow Kubrick Into ...
  • Venice Film Festival Awards Golden Lions ...
  • ‘Project Greenlight’ Returns, and They ...
  • Jon Stewart and Stephen Colbert Do Battle ...
  • 9 Films to See in Theaters or Stream ...
  • Attention, Documentary Filmmakers: New ...